Skip to content
History:Un-Attached
The Book Field Notes The Author Podcast Shop Find the book

Field note · 27 September 2026

Bonds Before Bowlby Had a Name

Darwin's 1839 notes on his son, published in 1877, already record smiles, a nurse's absence, and jealousy. Bowlby gave the research a name in 1951.

Bonds Before Bowlby Had a Name
History: Un-Attached

On 27 December 1839 Charles Darwin's first child, William Erasmus Darwin, was born. Darwin began a diary at once. He wrote later, in his autobiography, that he wanted the first dawn of expression, because he already thought the fine shades of a face must have come from somewhere gradual and natural. He did not publish the diary. It sat for thirty-seven years. In 1877 the journal Mind printed Hippolyte Taine's account of an infant, and Darwin answered with "A Biographical Sketch of an Infant," using notes he had made on the spot between 1839 and 1841. The Complete Work of Charles Darwin Online gives the essay as it appeared in Mind, volume 2, number 7, pages 285 to 294.

He is careful about what he can see. During the first week the baby sneezed, hiccuped, yawned, stretched, sucked, and screamed. On day seven a bit of paper on the sole made the foot jerk and the toes curl. A warm hand on the face seemed to start a wish to suck, which Darwin calls reflex, because experience of the breast could hardly have taught it so fast. At sixty-six days Darwin sneezed, and the child started, frowned, looked frightened, and cried; for an hour afterward small noises set him off. Darwin says that state would be called nervous in an older person. He is borrowing a word. He is not issuing a diagnosis.

The parts that matter for belonging are later, and they are ordinary. This infant smiled at forty-five days, a second infant at forty-six, and Darwin thought the smiles were real because the eyes brightened. They came mostly when the baby looked at his mother. At 110 days a pinafore thrown over the face and pulled away produced a small noise Darwin calls an incipient laugh. Near five months the boy "plainly showed his wish to go to his nurse." Darwin had no clear evidence that the child recognized anyone until nearly four months, and no spontaneous kiss until a little past a year, when the boy kissed the nurse who had been away for a short time. At six months and eleven days, if the nurse pretended to cry, the boy's mouth turned down. At fifteen and a half months, jealousy showed when Darwin fondled a large doll and when he weighed the infant sister. Darwin even notes the uncertainty about the nurse's name; the Darwin Online annotation says "possibly Mary Bennett."

None of this is attachment theory. It is a father with a notebook, a nurse whose absence registers, a mother whose face draws a smile, and a scientist who thinks the timing will differ from baby to baby. He says so in the first paragraph. The value of the sketch is that the observations are dated in days. You can argue with the interpretation. You cannot say he failed to notice who the child reached for. Parents today are still noticing the same thing, and The Parents' Perspective writes about it for them, starting with what a secure base looks like on an ordinary day.

Advice books came earlier, and they were advice

John Locke published Some Thoughts Concerning Education in 1693. Mark Goldie's chronology, in the Liberty Fund edition of Locke's Letter Concerning Toleration and other writings, lists that title under the year. A biographical note in the same library, drawing on older papers, says Locke drew up most of the book for the son of Edward Clarke, and that the letters to Clarke run from 1692 to 1702. So the famous treatise began as instructions to a particular father about a particular boy.

That is a different genre from Darwin's diary. Locke is telling a gentleman how to form a child: body, habit, tutor, curriculum. He is not sitting with a stopwatch over a smile. People in 1693 already had strong views about who should be near a child and what that nearness would do. They did not have Darwin's day-counts, and they did not have a twentieth-century research program. If you read Locke as a clinician, you have changed his job. If you read him as proof that "bonding" was invented in 1951, you have skipped a literature of nurses, tutors, and parental letters that treats early company as consequential.

What 1951 actually was

John Bowlby, a British psychiatrist, reviewed the literature on maternal deprivation for the World Health Organization. The monograph is Maternal Care and Mental Health. Frank C. P. van der Horst, Helen A. LeRoy, and René van der Veer, writing in Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science in 2008, describe it as his 1951 WHO report and say what it did and did not do. It gathered studies of children separated from caregivers. It did not rest on the kind of evidence Bowlby himself later wanted. The authors write that many of the findings were based on practical experience or on studies that were methodologically inadequate, and that there was not yet sound empirical evidence for the claims, which is one reason Bowlby turned toward ethology and, eventually, toward the three volumes Attachment (1969), Separation (1973), and Loss (1980).

They also place him in a crowd. Pediatrician Harry Bakwin, in 1942, had described infants at Bellevue Hospital in New York kept in cubicles by masked staff, and a mortality rate in infants under one year that fell from about 30–35 percent to under 10 percent after nurses were encouraged to hold and play with the children and parents were allowed to visit. Van der Horst and his coauthors are summarizing Bakwin, and a British Medical Journal editorial of that year, not presenting a new clinical trial. The numbers belong to that debate. They are a reason the debate became urgent. They are not a recipe you can lift into a household.

The sequence, then, is roughly this. Locke writes private educational advice that becomes a book in 1693. Darwin counts a son's expressions from the last days of 1839 and publishes them in 1877 because another psychologist has done something similar. Mid-century clinicians argue, often from hospital wards, that separation hurts. Bowlby, in 1951, files a report that makes the argument international and, by his own later standards and by later historians of science, overruns its data. The technical vocabulary of attachment is the later work. The notice that a baby marks who leaves the room is in Darwin's pages, with the nurse's name only half known.

C. V. Wooster's Searching for Bowlby follows the man who built that later vocabulary. This note stays upstream, with the diary and the report's limits.

A limit, said plainly

Nothing here is advice about your child. A historical diary cannot tell you whether a baby in front of you is safe, ill, or simply different from William Darwin. If a child in your care is in immediate danger, contact local emergency services. If you are worried about development, fear, or a caregiver's absence and the worry will not settle, the person to ask is a pediatrician or another licensed clinician who can see the child. An essayist in 1877 could watch his own household. He could not see yours, and neither can I.

Darwin's most useful sentence may be the unspectacular one: faculties arrive on different days in different infants. He watched one boy flinch at a snore, laugh at a pinafore, and sulk when a hat meant a walk that did not happen. The record is tender because it is specific. Specificity is what a label skips.

Whose daily presence would a careful diary of your own first year have had to mention, and who, if you wrote it now, would you be tempted to leave out?

Sources

  • Darwin Online: A biographical sketch of an infant, Mind, July 1877
  • Liberty Fund: chronology of Locke's life, ed. Mark Goldie
  • Liberty Fund: Locke biographical note
  • Van der Horst, LeRoy, and Van der Veer, Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science, 2008
ChartOrigin Timeline of World History poster showing 5,000 years of empires and civilizations

For the study wall · Exhibit

Five thousand years on a single sheet.

ChartOrigin’s Timeline of World History sets 21 countries and civilizations side by side, so you can see who was rising while someone else was falling. A good map to keep beside the archive boxes.

Code MSF6C takes 5% off.

See the poster at ChartOrigin

Affiliate link: we may earn a commission if you buy, at no extra cost to you.

Our picks

Recommended on Amazon

  • Cover of History: Un-Attached by C. V. Wooster History: Un-Attached By C. V. Wooster
  • Cover of Searching for Bowlby by C. V. Wooster Searching for Bowlby By C. V. Wooster
  • Cover of Mrs. Orcutt's Driveway by C. V. Wooster Mrs. Orcutt's Driveway By C. V. Wooster

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Working on your own attachment patterns? See the Secure Base downloads: an attachment workbook, a shadow-work journal and an adoption family kit.

← All field notes

History: Un-Attached

Historical figures. Emotional baggage. Better questions.

The Book Field Notes The Author More from C. V. Wooster Substack YouTube Etsy Shop Secure Base downloads About Contact Terms Privacy Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information Cookies Find the book
© 2026 HistoryUnattached. Amazon links are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.