Elizabeth I was twenty-five when she was crowned on 15 January 1559. The portrait the National Portrait Gallery in London calls the Coronation portrait shows her in cloth of gold that had been made for her half-sister Mary, holding the orb and sceptre. The gallery's catalogue entry says the painting appears to have been made in about 1600 and is probably a copy of a lost original from about 1559. Loose hair recalls the style of a queen consort. The orb and sceptre are the extra, the marks of a queen regnant. A picture painted near the end of the reign, repeating a face and a robe from the beginning, is already a mask: the accession, kept available for the annual celebration of 17 November.
The same gallery says of the Darnley portrait, dated about 1575, that it "was almost certainly painted from life, and the resulting pattern for the queen's face was to be repeated for the remainder of her reign" (National Portrait Gallery; the Wikimedia Commons record gives NPG 2082 and circa 1575). Earlier, in 1563, someone tried to make the queen's likeness a matter of rule. The attempt exists as a draft proclamation, not as a law. The draft proposed an approved pattern that other artists could then follow. The original draft, published in Archaeologia from the Paper Office, is in the handwriting of Secretary William Cecil, with his corrections, and it was found among his papers.
The draft's own preamble, as printed with that Archaeologia communication, complains that painters, printers, and engravers were already turning out portraits in which nobody had caught "the naturall representation" of her person, and that subjects were grumbling. It says the queen had been pressed by the council to allow one specially skilled painter access, despite her own unwillingness to sit, and to forbid other people from drawing her until a perfect pattern existed. Read that slowly. The document that is supposed to prove a vain queen micromanaging her image says she did not want to sit, and it survives in her secretary's corrected draft. A wish to stop bad pictures is not the same as a wish to be ageless. Later portraits did settle her features while her body aged. Emily Ballance Stewart, in a 2014 East Carolina University thesis, argues that the draft does the opposite of the story often told about a vain queen. It was never passed into law. Cecil corrected it. The text, Stewart writes, shows the council pressing an unwilling sitter, not a sitter directing a propaganda office. She also tracks what happened to that reluctance in print. Roy Strong's 1963 Portraits of Queen Elizabeth I still noted an "extraordinary reluctance" to sit. In the 1987 revision, Gloriana, Stewart finds the sentence rewritten so that the queen "urgently needed" to sit. The reluctance drops out. A mask can be manufactured by a later book as well as by a workshop.
Stewart's example of a picture made for a visit, rather than for a government pattern, is the Ditchley portrait. Sir Henry Lee commissioned it for the entertainments at his house during the queen's progress in 1592. The sitter stands on Oxfordshire, the county where Lee lived, because the picture served the host's entertainment, not because a clerk in London issued a face. Subjects wanted her head in their long galleries as a sign of loyalty. That demand explains a crowd of surviving portraits better than a single royal order that was never proclaimed. Readers should not pretend the 1563 draft was law, or that Cecil's pen was her diary.
The head on the dollar
Gilbert Stuart painted George Washington more than once. The Smithsonian's George Washington: A National Treasure site says Stuart painted his first portrait of Washington "probably in 1794-95," and that afterwards "Martha Washington asked to have her own portrait done, as well as another one of the President." Intended for Mount Vernon, they "are known as the Athenaeum portraits because the Boston Athenaeum acquired them after Stuart's death" (Smithsonian). Washington turns to his own right, toward the viewer's left; the Smithsonian page says "Washington faces left." The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency says the $1 note image "is based on a portrait painted by Gilbert Stuart" (OCC), and the U.S. Currency Education Program describes the Athenaeum portrait as "used for the 1869 series of U.S. notes and the current $1 banknote" (U.S. Currency Education Program).
Stuart's explanation of the mouth is physical, and it is easy to overread. He said that when he painted Washington, the president had just had a set of false teeth put in, "which accounts for the constrained expression so noticeable about the mouth and lower part of the face." The constraint is dentistry, reported by the painter. It is not a diagnosis of character. Martha asked for a portrait to live with. The United States got a pattern, the way Elizabeth's council had wanted a pattern, by a different route and without a draft proclamation.
Put the two heads next to each other and the mask is the repeatable part. The Wikimedia Commons description calls the Darnley portrait "the source of the face pattern called "The Mask of Youth" which would be used for authorized portraits of Elizabeth for decades to come." Stuart's head became the model for the $1 note. In both cases the sitter's day-to-day face (tired, ill, private, mid-sentence) is what the pattern leaves out. The Coronation portrait copies a robe from 1559 onto a panel from about 1600. The Athenaeum head copies a constrained mouth onto currency. Neither is a lie in the sense of a forged document. Both are selections that outlasted the sitting.
Questions for a famous face
Three questions sort a portrait faster than a mood. Is this the first version or a copy, and how many years sit between them? Who commissioned it, and for which room? What did the painter, or a secretary's draft, say about the sitter's willingness? Elizabeth's coronation image fails the first test if you treat it as an eyewitness panel from January 1559. Stuart's dollar bill fails the second if you treat it as Mount Vernon's domestic object. Cecil's draft fails the third if you quote it as the queen's vanity rather than as a councillor's attempt, never enacted, to police bad likenesses.
A mask can be politically useful and still be poor evidence of a private hour. The Ditchley picture is a magnificent piece of estate theater. It will not tell you what she said at supper. Stuart's comment about the teeth will not tell you whether Washington was lonely in Philadelphia. If you want the private self, you will need a letter, a bill, a diary kept by someone in the room. The portrait is the face that was allowed to travel.
When you next see a famous head used as if it were a personality, ask who paid for the pattern, and who was still allowed to look unlike it.
History: Un-Attached
Searching for Bowlby
Mrs. Orcutt's Driveway